NIB embraces medical tourism

5
1855
As good as a holiday, according to NIB.
As good as a holiday, according to NIB.

Health insurer NIB’s senior executives have defended the company’s plans to move into the medical tourism market, saying the phenomenon was “not new” and would help to grow earnings in its business.

“It’s not new. It is actually happening,” NIB chief executive Mark Fitzgibbon was quoted as telling shareholders at its annual meeting in Newcastle last week.

He said the question for NIB was about “how can we hitch our wagon to the global thematic of people travelling across borders for their healthcare”.

However, Australian Dental Association federal president Karin Alexander criticized the decision, telling The Australian newspaper that, while prices for offshore treatment seemed cheaper, there was no way that the quality of work performed overseas could be guaranteed.

“We have a very high level of regulation in Australia to ensure safety and we also have rules about security of the workforce and those elements aren’t there in most Asian countries,” she said.

“Dentistry is rarely a one-off operation, but instead requires ongoing consultation, and that requires an individual dentist who knows an individual and what their issues are. Any work done overseas can’t really be followed up anywhere in Australia.”

She said the sort of dental work that Australians went to Asia for was generally high-end operations such as crown work or implants.

“What worries me about having health funds try to provide some sort of quality assurance measures is just how independent they would be. If they employ someone to check out Asian dentists, would that person be fully independent or would they be paid for by the health fund?”

When questioned about the ADA’s opposition to the scheme (as well as other peak medical bodies) Mr Fitzgibbon said the two peak bodies were part of NIB’s consultation over the scheme.

“The response is not surprising,” he said. “You will always have a bias to the status quo. I’m confident they will accept this as a sensible option to improve the quality of something that is already happening.”

The ADA has put out a press release detailing the issues those travelling overseas for dental work must consider, including:

 Australian dentists provide a level of quality of service not matched in many parts of the world. They do this in a tight regulatory environment. Regulations cover the practitioners, the practice surgery, the treatment delivered, the equipment and materials used, and the infection control standards. There are few countries in the world that match this level of safety and quality.

 Will the health tourism provider be able to guarantee this same level of expertise and safety and quality?

 Complex or detailed procedures carry a risk. Having the work done overseas by practitioners that you are not familiar with, in an environment where you do not know the quality of education and training of the practitioner, the regulatory measures in place to guarantee safety and quality of treatment, nor the quality of equipment or products to be used on your treatment only escalates that risk.

 Treatment which in Australia, would usually be done in stages to allow for adequate healing, is rushed to fit in with travel plans rather than align with best practice.

 If problems arise there may be no guarantee that the provider will remedy the situation.

 Any remedial work is unlikely to be covered by any Australian health insurance cover.

 

 

Previous articleEnglish language skills and criminal history standards under review
Next articleBlurred lines

5 COMMENTS

  1. Ethical members of the ADA ought to be concerned about the hypocritical warnings by their executive of the dangers of having overseas dental procedures performed, when they maintain their deafening silence on the non-consensual outsourcing to Asia of crowns, bridges etc by over 60% of their members, to be manufactured in the same unregulated conditions from materials of unverifiable content. At least these patients are making a conscious decision to take these risks for the benefit of cheaper dentistry, as opposed to the deception of the Australian dentists’ trusting patients, all for the sake of increased profit margins. I believe the integrity of the profession and the ADA in particular will be seriously damaged following the media publicity regarding this issue which is impending.

  2. What is annoying me is the ada, have openly encourraged the outsorcing of dental devices,and hold australian technicians with little to no reguard i the majority of cases, of 60% of south australian dental work is being sent overseas, leaving the dental technology industry in tatters, do patients get told there crowns, dentures ect are being mae overseas, no, and most are still charged full price as if we australians had made them, am i happy to see this, no, but it is about time the ada and denists in gemeral found out they are just as disposable as us technicians whom they have deserted for profit.

  3. Well said Paul Hade, following the deregistration of technicians anyone off the street can manufacture body parts in Australia and that street may not be in Australia.

    The ADA is totally hypocritical to preach about unregulated industry when they have done nothing to protect the public from imported dental restorations which bypass TGA. If they are genuine about concerns for the public they would actively support registration of technicians and ensure their members only use restorations manufactured by registered techs using TGA approved materials. The current situation totally contradicts the comments Karin Alexander makes.

    The medical tourism industry will exploit this fact and simply say that’s where your crowns are made anyway, they will suggest a crown or a week in Thailand and a crown at a health fund endorsed practice.

  4. Hi there, I am a Brisbane based dentist and joint founder of dentalaware.com.au (with Brisbane tech Paul Hade)and it worries me that you techs are not working together to fund a publicity campaign on this issue. I am doing my best to help you but you need to reach that tipping point of public awareness to be sucessful, which means $$$$. I know no patient would willingly want a Chinese crown when for the same fee that could get an Australian crown, but dentists continue to carry on deceiving their patients, with some dentists even lying on the country of origin, when questioned by savvy patients. I’m thinking perhaps a full page advertorial in the Australian and bill boards may be the way to go?? Dentalaware car magnets are available for about $40 for a set of two (the magnet has the words ‘Is your dentist ripping you off’,with the words dentalaware.com.au shown underneath)and are available from Paul for $40 a set of two (0738782251).This is an easy win once the public is aware! Hammer OHPA!!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here